The Selection Committee is a group of people that decides who gets hired for a job. The committee members must all be impartial and unbiased in their evaluation of candidates. Ideally, the committee should include supervisors from different parts of the company to make sure that no one person has too much influence over the decision. The group should also be diverse in terms of gender, race, ethnicity and functional expertise. This diversity will help the committee get a wider range of perspectives regarding a candidate’s qualifications.
Choosing the right committee members is critical to selecting the best applicants. In addition to ensuring that all of the committee’s interests are taken into account, it is essential that each member has enough knowledge about the position requirements and background to be able to make an informed decision. In addition, the members should have a good working relationship with each other. If not, it could be difficult to reach a consensus.
In addition to the standard criteria for selection committee members – a record of distinguished public service, technical expertise in innovative technology and senior leadership experience as president or other senior executive of a university or major research institution – it is helpful to have someone on the committee with specialized skills and knowledge that may be important for a particular issue being considered. This can include a person with a unique perspective on the national security environment, someone who has been involved in a particular industry or someone who has an international background.
It is also important to keep in mind that the Selection Committee is not just responsible for selecting the at-large teams, but they must also seed the teams. This is a very complicated process that involves making sure that teams who played each other during the regular season (or once in the conference tournament) don’t meet in the same regional final, and avoiding matchups of top-tier teams until at least the Sweet 16.
The selection committee usually doesn’t begin the seeding process until after all the conference tournaments have finished. In some cases, this can leave less than a hour between the last game and when the brackets are unveiled on Selection Sunday. Then, the committee has to work out some incredibly tricky arrangements based on how conference favorites play against each other and how many at-large spots are left.
Another criterion that the committee takes into consideration is the “Eye Test.” This is basically the committee’s opinion of how good each team is, and it is very subjective. It probably wouldn’t hurt to have a former bookmaker on the Selection Committee, but they would need to swear off betting on pro football games 365 days a year!
It is also important for the Selection Committee to stick to the agenda during the meeting. They should only bring up new business when it is appropriate and do their best to avoid lengthy discussions that are off topic or a waste of time. In addition, the Committee Chair should ensure that everyone has a chance to speak and to make their point.